|
SAN DIEGO—"Various
uses of quantitative EEG are emerging as possible ways
to predict positive and adverse psychotropic medication
responses," reported Daniel A. Hoffman, MD, and while no
one is ready to toss out the DSM-IV just yet,
there is now increased evidence that the use of
referenced EEG (rEEG) can sometimes do better than
clinical diagnostic techniques in determining which
psychotropic drugs will help an individual patient or in
predicting whether a particular patient will do better
without any medication at all.
According to Mark Schiller, MD, rEEG is a patented
system that uses EEG and quantitative EEG (QEEG) to
characterize features of brain function underlying a
broad range of psychiatric syndromes. In the procedure,
a patient's EEG data are compared against a large,
clinical outcome database of heterogeneous EEG/QEEG
results and diverse medication responses. The patient's
EEG data are then mathematically classified and
correlated with neuroactive medications likely to
improve brain function in that particular case. The
growing EEG/QEEG database currently includes children
from age 6 to adults age 90 and covers a broad range of
DSMM diagnoses.
In a
previous multisite study presented by Drs. Hoffman and
Schiller and colleagues at the 158th Annual Meeting of
the American Psychiatric Association, 77% of 247
patients with treatment-refractory psychiatric disorders
who underwent rEEG received subsequent medication
changes as a result of information obtained through that
testing. These medication changes were ones "that the
psychiatrist would never have chosen without the aid of
the rEEG," Dr. Hoffman said.
BIOMARKER BASIS
"rEEG is surfacing as a way to provide psychiatrists
with a set of clinically useful biomarkers to guide
physicians' pharmacotherapeutic choices," Dr. Hoffman
said. Based on the number of such biomarkers, physicians
can then determine how likely a patient is to respond to
a particular type of medication, he explained. In cases
where the rEEG report comes back showing a low biomarker
prevalence, Dr. Hoffman has found, many of these
patients feel better without any medications, during
follow-up that so far has lasted two to nine months.
"Whether some of them will need medications later has
yet to be determined, but in all cases, if they should,
the rEEG report suggests that from a physiological
perspective, they had not been on the right
psychotropics to date and that implementing the correct
medications should make a significant difference."
CASE IN POINT
In
an update at the 17th Annual Meeting of the American
Neuropsychiatric Association, Dr. Hoffman described the
difference that rEEG made in the cases of three patients
at the Neuro-Therapy Clinic in Englewood, Colorado.
The
first was a 33-year-old woman who came in with her
husband; both expressed discouragement and doubt that
they would ever be able to live a normal life because of
her depression and anxiety. At the time of her visit,
the patient had tried 22 psychotropic medications.
"Despite the challenging medication discontinuation
tapering for the rEEG testing, the patient was feeling
so well without medication that to date, she has decided
to only use trazodone for sleep," Dr. Hoffman reported.
Her scores on the Beck Anxiety and Beck Depression
scales both decreased significantly at follow-up.
There was also a 29-year-old woman with bipolar
disorder. She was taking six psychotropic drugs "yet
still felt suicidal, labile, sleep deprived, and
exhausted," Dr. Hoffman said. Following rEEG, which
showed low biomarker prevalence, she went off all
medications and said she felt "wonderful." At two-month
follow-up, she remained symptom-free and
medication-free.
The
third case was a 15-year-old male who had been diagnosed
with oppositional defiant disorder and ADHD and had been
on dextroamphetamine for five years. His medication was
tapered off prior to the rEEG evaluation, and he
remained medication-free thereafter; his parents
reported that his behavior was back to where it had been
before he took the stimulant drug.
REASONS FOR rEEG
Other reasons to consider the use of rEEG include the
likelihood of increased remission rates as well as lower
health care costs, according to Dr. Hoffman. He added
that in reviewing his cases in which rEEG was used, he
found that fewer medications were needed, medication
compliance increased, and patients recovered more
quickly.
"By
targeting the medication response with objective
evidence, the previously reluctant practitioner might
now choose to use a medication with a higher side-effect
profile. Having a neurophysiologic basis for that
decision increases the comfort level and likelihood of
the prescriber using these medications with greater
confidence and increased success," he said. "Certainly,
more controlled research seems warranted to pursue
rEEG's place in modern psychiatry."
—Jean McCann |